Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Word Vomit

**I talked to Aaron after I had posted my second in-country assignment and was telling him what a hard time I had trying to write a cohesive paper. I have struggled with the concept of writing blog posts that express my feelings completely because they are public. This became especially apparent as I wrestled with my experiences in Gugulethu and how to gather my thoughts into a paper. As an exercise, Aaron challenged me to write another paper and just free write. Below is the result of that process.

Pity and Shame


I like to think of myself as someone who does not live my life looking down on other people. I do not feel that it is fair to feel pity for someone else—no matter how horrible their life is. I know that if I were in an unfortunate situation I would not want people coming into my space and feeling sorry for me. Those emotions and energy could be put to better use and are not serving me, or the person experiencing them. I know that this perspective could come off as selfish, but there is a difference between pity and empathy. However, the question comes as how to empathize with a situation that I have no real grasp of what it is like.


This is something that I worried about coming into this experience. How do you empathize without minimizing another individual? I feel that pity is an automatic response when we see something sad and then you jump to punishing yourself for things that you have that others do not. It is an automatic human reaction to compare ourselves to others and feel sorry for those less fortunate. As creatures in this greater circle of life and evolution we have been bred to be competitive. It is the nature of competition to take note of disparities between individuals and then use it to ones advantage. Even though this is part of human nature I think people counter it with pity. The point is not to let pity get in the way of productively contributing something good to a situation.


My time in Gugulethu has given me insight into the concept of pity and shame. People can have very different perspectives on the same situation. The thing that sticks with me is when Fundi talked about the ‘sad tourists’ who drive through the townships and look out the window dejected and hopeless. This really bothers me, because they do not have a concept of the community any further than what they can see out of the bus windows. Pity seems to go hand in hand with guilt—people guilt themselves into feeling pity so that they can say they felt something and had some sort of reaction. However, I think that pity is worse than feeling nothing at all, especially when you do not really have a concept of what is actually happening around you.


What I appreciated the most about my experience in Gugulethu was that I was able to be a visitor in a community and actually observe what was going on around me in an authentic manner. Staying with host families, walking around the community, going into some of the remotest shacks and seeing people on the brink of death are not things that you would ordinarily see unless you consciously choose to have those experiences. As hard as all of the things we saw were, and despite the emotional drain that I felt, I left Gugulethu more of a human than when I started.


Pity gives people the illusion that they are superior. It gives them power over the people that they feel sorry for. It is not concrete power, but they have a mental leg up to those in the less fortunate situation. Superiority perhaps serves as an outlet to feel that you have control over a situation that is so complicated there is no way it will be solved in the near future. It is almost like a defense mechanism to the powerless feelings that stem from some of the situations we were put in. If the people on the tour buses actually got off of the bus and talked to people on the street they would realize that there is no place for their pity in Gugulethu. The people we saw are probably happier that half of America—not because of their situation but because they have a community that they can depend on. They have their priorities straight in terms of their cultural values, sense of family and the importance they place on community. If people could look past the exterior they would find people. Just people.


One of my themes for the week that we stayed in Gugulethu was the concept of power. We exercised an immense amount of power by simply being white—even young children were fascinated by the color of our skin. We exercised power when we descended in a group of 16 or more on someone’s home. What do you do with this power and how do you use it to do good? However, I did not feel like I had the power to actually affect any concrete change.


One of the first days in Gugulethu I realized that the shacks did not bother me as much as I thought they would. My initial reaction to this was that I was slightly mental. People were living and dying in structures made of sheet metal that leak and do not have a solid door. I came to realize that it was not that people living in that kind of poverty does not make me upset, it is that you have to learn to see beyond the exterior. And you also have to shift your perception of what is beautiful. You need to look at the colorful exterior of the houses and the idyllic nature of laundry being hung out on a clothesline. If you look beyond the literal exterior of Gugulethu you can learn to appreciate the beauty that stems from the people and the culture. I honestly never believed that I could feel so accepted and loved when I was surrounded by people who could not be more different from myself. I do not know why I felt this way—I am not sure I was even conscious of it until I was proven wrong.


The spirit of the people we met is what helped to sustain me throughout the week. While I had my moments when I was overwhelmed and upset I was also able to leave with a positive attitude. I would have loved to spend more time in Gugulethu getting to know the people and spending time in such a nurturing environment. I often grapple with who I am in the context of others. I just realized that this could be interpreted and related to the African concept of Ubuntu. However, at home I am concerned about my relation with others because I am scared that I am going to be judged. In Gugulethu there was no pressure to conform to what was happening around you and people were ready to accept you just how you were at the precise moment. I could let go of the baggage that I carry with my in my daily life and just be myself because there was no one there questioning—they were just accepting and loving.


The concept of understanding who you are in relation to others is an important life skill—especially for leadership. However, I think that America has twisted this for me because the relations with others have to be fabricated and then judged. How can you expect to authentically engage with a community when you are too concerned about what others think? I always feel as though people are watching my every move and if you misstep they will not be there to catch you but to put you down for making a mistake.


I am was not raised religious and normally do not attend any kind of religious worship because it makes me feel uncomfortable—and not in a way I can learn from but just like I am somewhere that I do not belong. Perhaps this is why I shy away from religion—I do not feel comforted, just alienated. Maybe this is a personal problem, but at J.L. Zwane it was not the same. While I do not identify myself as Christian, specifically, I did not feel like anyone was trying to push an agenda or judge me for my perspective. I was no less of an individual because I do not prescribe to the Christian faith or take communion. In a previous blog post I wrote about how a lot of Spiwo’s sermon resonated with the leadership lessons I have learned and believe in. Why do people feel the need to label faith and spirituality as this denomination or that religion when we all have the common goal of living a fulfilling and moral life?


On the flip side, if there is a God how can he allow people to go hungry and die in a shack with no water or heat? Supposedly God loves everybody, so why are people living in such horrible conditions and having to deal with things that no human being should have to face? This has always been my problem with believing in God. How is it comforting that a just God is sitting by and letting small children go hungry or take responsibility of their siblings because the parents died? Despite all of this happening right in the congregations backyard people still have immense faith. They can sing their feelings, and yell their prayers, and support one another in times of difficulty. The fact that this is so strongly entrenched in their faith was inspiring to me and made me question my skepticism. There has to be some reason why these people can get through each day and still have such a positive outlook on life.


Then I am always skeptical and since I only scratched the surface of J.L. Zwane is it not as good as it seems from an outsiders perspective? The church is such a huge part of the community and forms a community within the township of Gugulethu and everyone is only human. There would be huge opportunities for power to go awry. I do want to believe this because that is the first church that I feel like I could become a part of. Ironic given that we were the only white people besides one other lady. If I was going to be in South Africa for a longer period of time I would want to continue attending services on Sunday. I have always felt that maybe religion was missing from my life but I have not found a venue to be able to explore this. I have never found a place where I did not feel pressured to jump in with both feet and not question. Part of the reason I was sad to leave Gugulethu was because I felt that I may have had this opportunity here and I would not be able to utilize it.


Coming back to not judging the exterior. The color of someone’s skin is such a barrier to people. I even notice myself making generalizations or associating certain feelings with certain ethnic groups or people that have a different skin color from my own. I do not think of myself as a racist person, but this experience has taught me to break down cultural barriers. In the end we are all just people. This is very easy to say but not easy to act on until you have hands on experience and evidence that tells you it is actually true. Up until this past week I was probably more racist and less accepting than I would like to think. However, Gugulethu was a safe environment to learn this lesson and not be judged and for that I am thankful.


A lot of my thoughts about pity stem from my understanding and interpretation of Ayn Rand’s philosophy, Objectivism. Rand gets a lot of flack because she stresses the importance of putting yourself first and honoring the individual. Basically you cannot hope to help someone else until you learn to accept who you are and your place in the world. There is also a component of others can only do so much for you until you take ownership of your life and experiences. This was very hard for me to grapple with when we were seeing people in such horrible living situations with no obvious way out. It was almost as if there was nothing they could do about how they were living even if they had wanted to. Since they had no power this made me feel like I should be doing something, but there was nothing I could really do. And the automatic response to this was to feel bad for them and guilty for how I lead my own life. I also felt that if I my automatic response was not pity that I was not a compassionate person—or really human at all.


I am also concerned that some of my feelings were the result of those around me projecting onto me. It is hard to separate some of my personal experiences and emotions from the group and determine what my initial reaction was before the group reflected. I also struggle with sharing my perspective with others when it is different. My scientific personality makes me think that there is only one right answer. Even though I know this is not that case with feeling and emotion sometimes I am concerned that I will not express myself correctly and then be judged. I know that I need to learn to take constructive criticism and not take things personally but it is hard to share things that have reached so close to my heart and soul. What we did and saw has made me question who I am as an individual, how I fit into groups, my role as a global citizen and the whole reflective process. Nothing fits into the nice neat box and that makes me uncomfortable. How can I begin to process my experiences when I cannot even sort them out and get my feelings straight?


To bring this full circle I think that this week has taught me to not feel shameful about who I am and how I live. Taking a cue from the people living in shacks in a South African township I maybe will able to take steps to not feel ashamed of how I feel about certain things or my opinions and perceptions of situations. There is no right answer, it is just important that you share your thoughts and feelings in a respective manner. Having a safe space is the most important thing because I have realized that I am not going to open up and really share myself unless I feel that there will people to catch me and not judge me. Who knew that spending 5 days in a township would prompt me to evaluate how I present myself and interact with others, question my spirituality and faith.

No comments:

Post a Comment